924 Columbus Ave

Good crisp 👍🏻

Trash

Right out the oven, good slices, ratio is a lil' more on the cheese side, crispy

Good looking slice. Undercarriage holds up, no New York flop. Sauce has good flavor but feels very salty. Didn’t eat the crust after tasting; it’s kind of crumbly and bland. On the smaller side but only $2.50. The seemingly over salty sauce kept this out of the 7’s, but a slice worth having.

It's good

The crunch mixed with the chewiness is outstanding. And PiePie always delivers with yummy cheese and perfect sauce ratio. Crust was delish too.

Normally heavy cheese no bueno. Pie pie cheeses it up and its still pretty good! Dough is thin and the sauce is a non factor. Not Columbus’ best, but respectable little pop in slice spot.

one bite, def not a 7 Frankie

I have to say I was impressed with Pie Pie slices. We tried white, cheese, roni, and margarita. The margarita was the best. All were very good. A little oily, but very quality sauce and dough was really good. The other slices on display looked dope too. Gonna have to try more late on but for now; that’s a review.

Great crisp on the crust. Great value slice.

Solid everyday NYC cheese slice. Could use some more kick in the sauce. Decent crisp.

Great pizza !

Good flavor. Crust has a nice crunch. Minimal flop and not a lot of grease. Solid slice

Crunchy, flavorful, amazing

Italian sausage is a must