The personal pie i had, half plain and half pepperoni was very thick and doughy. The sauce was nice and sweet, but a little too one dimensional in order for it to be described as good. It didn't taste horrible, but it lacked crisp. New Rochelle in general is a hit or miss city for pizza, just like my home city in Mt Vernon. The cake slices on the left I got from them were both amazing, and the wings on the right I baked myself.