A Slice of New York

Meatball and ricotta. Best combo and best pie in the Pittsburgh area.

One of the best NY style pizzas I’ve had. I’m a more Detroit/sicilian kind of guy, but top tier flavors. Sourdough as the crust might not be for everyone but the cheese is best part. Try it before he leaves!

Most of the time when I see New York in the name I am skeptical. This place is the real McCoy. Hands down the best pizza in western PA

As the name says..this is truly a slice of New York pizza. The most authentic New York style pizza around the Pittsburgh area or really the tri state area. Good amount of sauce and a very cheesy slice. Chewy, thin crust. Folds perfectly. Traveled over an hour to get there and it’s worth it. Little bit of grease but it doesn’t drip off, I would prefer a little more crisp/char but overall a perfect NY pie.

Excellent sauce and cheese thin pizza crust a little dry very good though

Solid NY style pizza

Best Facebook account ever

Best pizza in this area.

Ignore the fact that this pizza is on the ground. I brought it too my uncle and he sat down on the driveway to eat some. Lol Didn’t have any drinks for my very salty pie. THE GOOD I loved the stringy cheese and the charred crust and overall crunchiness of the pie. Pepperoni had a premium that I have trouble describing. THE BAD This pie suffered from one two things. It’s very salty and the sauce is a tad bit too sweet for my liking. I’ve had pizza from all over the US. This was the first pie I ever had that salt content was issue. It’s an good pizza and it’s definitely better than a lot of the competition around. But definitely not the best. My girlfriend gave it a 9. (Rookie score) Uncle gave it a 6.6 I give it a

Ordered the plain cheese pizza and garlic knots This is one outstanding pizza. The homemade crust was cooked perfectly and allowed for easy holding and when biting, the cheese stayed on the crust. Delicious! This sauce is light and only adds to the pure satisfaction. I highly recommend A Slice of New York pizza!

Quite literally one of the best Pizza spots in PGH/Western Pa area. Fresh ingredients with phenomenal taste! No flop, terrific undercarriage and crunch! It’s a knockout! Keep it up Sean and A Slice of New York team! Dave, get your ass here!

One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Every bite is incredible. Hands down, favorite pizza in Pittsburgh.

Today was the first day I tried this pizza and I have to say, it’s the best around in the area. Quality through and through.

Hands down the best Pizza in this area! Only a very few other places that can compete but they aren’t close to me. Only true pizza aficionados will appreciate what Sean puts into his craft.

The pizza is phenomenal! The crust, sauce and cheese all blend perfectly together! The plain cheese and pepperoni pies are amazing! The Sicilian is hands down the best I have ever had!

Can’t find a better, more authentic pizza around. This has definitely become my go to for pizza since they opened a couple years ago.

Pictured is their white pie, but above all- their cheese pie is NY authentic. Anywhere else claiming to be in the Pittsburgh area is lying & the owner Sean himself is from NYC. Great flavor, stretch, and the dough is to die for. You won’t regret trying it and they sell out fast!