Adriatico's New York Style Pizza

Best Sicilian style in town.

Very thick. Not my preferred style but decent for what it is.

Ordered Extra thin crust. Absolutely delicious. Sauce is cooked for hours and only one person knows how to make it. It’s a beautiful sauce with great level of garlic nice crisp and excellent undercarriage not sure what happened when Dave had it six or seven years ago at the old location, but it didn’t look right and I find it hard to believe he’d dislike it that much; he needs to try it again. Delicious

Sorry but not sorry. Best pizza

Expected better. Very bland cheese. Like the crisp on the crust. Disappointed.

I’ve never understood the hype here. Skimpy on sausage, a bit ridiculous. Very bland and not much flavor. Crust is best part.

Sorry I forgot to take a picture but this one shows I was in Columbus. The good: the garlic breadstick knots were extremely good, probably the best I’ve ever had. The service was fantastic as well. The not so good: the pizza was nondescript and pedestrian. It was interesting to me how good the bread could be but the pizza was very average.

Underwhelming slice of pie. Dough of thick and no flavor. Reminded me of a Chuck E Cheese pizza. Sauce was decent enough to make the pot edible when not drunk. Meatball sub was also bland. Other places to eat in town. Pass on this one.

Really was expecting more, based off aesthetics I thought this pizza was going to knock my dick off but instead I was bored by the lack of flavor. Not bad just doesn’t excite me in anyway. Maybe should of got a standard cheese instead of the ricotta but for a specialty pizza? Totally average! My taste buds are not picking up on anything exciting!

A bit greasy, but the crust is super crispy and cheese is very good. If you like pepperoni then it’s even better, like this one.

The cheese has a great flavor…Greasy. The sauce is ok… Greasy. The crust is average… Greasy. The overall pizza has a good flavor but have I mentioned it’s greasy? Great drunk OSU party pizza (just bring paper towels for the grease), but not New York style.

Got better as I ate more but still kind of below average. Chewy crust and lots of grease, with not much sauce. Average pie.

This one had high expectations, and it was just middle of the road pizza. I question calling it New York style as that isn’t how I would describe it to someone. I’d call the crust/style Dominos-like.

Best I had in Columbus. Tried a ton of places downtown and around campus. This is the one to try. Good cheese and good taste. Cool place

Super Greasy, crust was sub-par. Tasted like Ruby Tuesday but way more expensive.

Always good, great sauce. Good crunch on the crust but being cut in squares leaves some soft middle pieces.

Good pizza but a little too heavy and greasy.

Not a bad pizza. Overhyped, however. Very doughy, good pieces of pepperoni.

Very good pizza!

The sauce is the best part and the crust is subpar. Definitely a good gameday or late night pizza but nothing special.