Agnello's Pizza

Holy shit, this is incredible. The new pizza to beat in rockland for me. They achieve the near impossible and the perfect bite; when it’s chewy warm and crispy at the same time. The holy trinity. Fresh tangy sauce and a perfect creamy mozzarella balance with a touch of basil make this a travel at least an hour pizza. It was so good I called them on the phone to tell them. Dave has to get here. Has to.

Typical coal-fired margherita, but verrrrry floppy. If cooked properly I may have given a higher score.

Could be a touch crispier but flavor is top notch

Really good pizza, crust is thin with good crisp. Sauce is very flavorful with a bit of sweetness to it. Fresh mozz to top it off, I’ve had the new havens/delorenzos/angelos of the pizza world and this ranks just a tier below

Rocklands best pizza hands down

This stuffed crust, double cheese, double pepperoni 🔥🔥🔥

Best pizza spot in new city

Best pizza in the area

This place is what John's on Bleeker dreams of being. Great crust, sauce, dough, and the coal fire oven gives it great crisp. A MUST go in Rockland county.

Excellent slice, sauce is very tasty, crisp thin crust

Fresh mozzarella, tasty sauce, awesome crust. Mozzarella sticks and croutons are also to die for.

Great pizza!