Aiello's Pizzeria

Same Aiello’s as Squirrel Hill. It feels a little unreasonable to pay $22 (cash only) for a large cheese pizza, especially in Westmoreland County. I used to swear by Aiello’s, and when I first made my account I gave the OG one in Squirrel Hill a 9 🤯 Thankfully, I’ve matured a pizza connoisseur and realized this is barely an 8. The sauce isn’t as good as I used to think. The flourey crust used to be unique to me, but I’ve had places that have executed that style better since. It’s still a good pie. It better be a good pizza at $22 a pie! Good thing there’s a lot of good pizza places in the Penn Trafford school district so you don’t go broke at this place.

One of the best pizzas that I ever had. Highly recommend.

Freshest, highest quality ingredients

Crisp crust and ingredients tasted very fresh. Chicago pizza tasted fresh also excellent

Simply beautiful, quality ingredients the taste is phenomenal highly highly recommend it.

Best Chicago style I have had in the area.

True artisan pizza. Chicago Deep dish, Detroit, you name it! It’s done the right way!

Absolutely perfect undercarriage and crisp! Sauce and cheese and great!

Nothing special about this pie, on the pricey side

Best pizza joint in Western PA, hands down. Fresh ingredients, homemade dough, huge slices. Something special made every day. Can’t beat the quality. One slice is all you need but two slices you will be stuffed. This beats any place in the city. I have had some of the best in NY/Philly/Jersey and I still have this place up there

Chicago style, delicious, but sauce was a little too sweet. Overall the best pizza we've had in the area.

the grandma siciliano. this is by far the best pizza in the pittsburgh area.

One bite everybody knows the rules!! We found this place off the one bite app and it had a review of 7.8 I thought the pizza was really good the crust was amazing!!! My only complaint is that they put a little to much Italian seasoning on it but was a really good slice !!!

Quality ingredients wow