AJ's NY Pizzeria

Absolutely perfect if you love sweet sauce. Order it well done

Came back to try the plain cheese. Rubbery cheese and a floppy crust. Not as good as the last slice I had here. Very average to below average.

Cheese pizza was overall solid. Minimal flop, decent undercarriage, good flavor. Crust is thin, but not paper thin. Also got a slice of a chicken bacon ranch, which honestly outshined the cheese slice. Their best is probably in the various flavors rather than classic cheese. Also had a caesar salad, which was about what you’d expect - no complaints. However, it came with two garlic knots which were doughy and undercooked. They were not eaten and were not taken into account when scoring the pizza. *Rating is purely for cheese slice.

Solid pizza. Perfect cheese to meat to sauce ratio. Crust cooked to a nice crisp. Not too crispy. Sauce is more sweet than savory. This is the 18th and 8th.

Pepperoni slice had literally ZERO flop.. Great flavor with a nice crisp crust.. this is SOLID pizza

Started off crisp then got soggy, might have been because I took so long to eat it but oh well 6.9

Crust is elite. Sauce is good. The closer you get to the center of the pizza there is less sauce and seems sloppy.

Good slice no flop

Good pizza. Sauce is a little too sweet.

Great flavor. Sauce is a little sweet at the end. Too much flop, but a Solid pizza. Best in town.

Crunch is great, but not a fan of the sauce.

Definitely underwhelmed not bad though I got the little apple pizza

Paper thin. Good crisp. Sauce 👍🏻. Could use less cheese. The Italian sausage slice on the right hit the spot!

Pretty solid, but not an 8

Great pizza. Good sauce good crust no flop. Definitely the best pizza in Manhattan.

Great crust, good sauce, but the cheese is average. But sex

Great slice. Crust is amazing and sauce is really good. Very little New York flop...would highly recommend!

Best pizza in MHK. Crispy, good flavor, good cheese

Best pizza in mhk

Best in Manhattan, that's a for sure.

Best pizza in town