Albert's Pizza Shop

I googled “oldest pizza places on Long Island” and this place popped up… since 1957?!! I’m in. Didn’t have any old school vibe on the inside, all young kids working ~ not what I was hoping to find ~ no display, no pie even ready actually.. had to wait 15-20 min but that’s ok ~ got a freebie. It’s good! Crust was nice and soft but it was a football pie really… rarely see that.. overall flavor good. Bonus review: that Grandpa or upside down… very strange taste on the sauce, not to my liking… I’m going 6.8 on that one. Looked good though 🤷🏻‍♂️ Since 1957… 65 years. No one over 23 working there. Weird math ay oh. Lol

Crispy upside down . Good sauce

Best. Slice. Ever. I’ve lived in New York my whole life and there’s no slice like an Alberts square slice ❤️ I even have them stored in my phone

place is known for its old fashioned sicilian .. it’s actually pretty good the dough has a good grinch and the combination with the sauce on top cheese on the bottom isn’t bad... it’s pretty standard

Best on long island.. hands down..its about the square slice not the traditional.. amazing

I got a cheese slice and the upside down slice but this review is for the cheese slice. Very thin, a little flop but crispy, good flavor in the sauce, nice cheese and crispy crust. I'm very impressed

Rating 6.6 *Enlarge Video* idk why it cropped half my face Very Shocking how below average this place was might have to try it again cause I just can’t believe I didn’t like this place *The score was the average between the slices

Great flavor! Little Copaigue flop, yet still crispy. The sauce and cheese taste great. Definitely lives up to the hype.

My specialty the vodka slice. What a great slice from this low key, hole in the wall pizza joint. Felt like I was in the early 90s walking in here. A great slice the sauce was like Nonna’s vodka sauce from the old country. The crust was stale or maybe burnt - whatever it was it wasn’t helping. Tastes better than it looks. A solid slice.