Pretty good crust, overall a decent slice. The squares might be the way to go.
Order now on Slice
Order Albert's Pizza Shop
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
jay.marine8/27/22, 11:53 p.m.
I googled “oldest pizza places on Long Island” and this place popped up… since 1957?!! I’m in. Didn’t have any old school vibe on the inside, all young kids working ~ not what I was hoping to find ~ no display, no pie even ready actually.. had to wait 15-20 min but that’s ok ~ got a freebie. It’s good! Crust was nice and soft but it was a football pie really… rarely see that.. overall flavor good. Bonus review: that Grandpa or upside down… very strange taste on the sauce, not to my liking… I’m going 6.8 on that one. Looked good though 🤷🏻♂️ Since 1957… 65 years. No one over 23 working there. Weird math ay oh. Lol
gabrielia.vigs12/2/19, 5:55 p.m.
Best. Slice. Ever. I’ve lived in New York my whole life and there’s no slice like an Alberts square slice ❤️ I even have them stored in my phone
chris.bozza11/6/19, 5:26 p.m.
place is known for its old fashioned sicilian .. it’s actually pretty good the dough has a good grinch and the combination with the sauce on top cheese on the bottom isn’t bad... it’s pretty standard
keith.zimmerli6/23/19, 5:06 p.m.
Best on long island.. hands down..its about the square slice not the traditional.. amazing
b..fleischman5/15/19, 10:46 p.m.
I got a cheese slice and the upside down slice but this review is for the cheese slice. Very thin, a little flop but crispy, good flavor in the sauce, nice cheese and crispy crust. I'm very impressed
oneill1bite3/17/19, 8:06 p.m.
Rating 6.6 *Enlarge Video* idk why it cropped half my face Very Shocking how below average this place was might have to try it again cause I just can’t believe I didn’t like this place *The score was the average between the slices
296 views•2 likes
richie.speruggia12/30/18, 9:11 p.m.
Great flavor! Little Copaigue flop, yet still crispy. The sauce and cheese taste great. Definitely lives up to the hype.
victorvodkasauce12/16/18, 6:36 a.m.
My specialty the vodka slice. What a great slice from this low key, hole in the wall pizza joint. Felt like I was in the early 90s walking in here. A great slice the sauce was like Nonna’s vodka sauce from the old country. The crust was stale or maybe burnt - whatever it was it wasn’t helping. Tastes better than it looks. A solid slice.