Alfie's Pizza

Travel from Long Island back to Queens for this!

Wow

8.6 for the Margherita slice and 9.8 for the upside-down, I've never had a sqare that's better than this.. ..

Wouldnt go out of my way for this

Upside down was great. Chicken ceasar was solid too. Liked the place a lot!!

Super satisfying legendary spot here!! Crispy pillowy goodness with hearty chunky sauce with grated cheese between the silky mozz that was off the charts! Cash only great people an absolute must try!!

The regular slice is above 8, the grandma is 8.5 the upside down is 8.9, if the lady owner heats it up....

Good, average pizza. The plain is much better than the grandma. Which to me, is rare. Had never happened.

This rating is for the upside down. Definitely the go to slice here. Parmesan on top adds nice flavor. The regular was a 6.8. Come for the upside down

Nothing like finding mold on you shitty slice . Total trash

Regular: dough is excellent sauce tastes delicious really good slice 8.1 Sicilan: it has a good crispness to the bottom sauce is amazing. This is the real deal. One of the best sicilan slices I've ever eaten 9.2 Upsidedown: perfect crust, again sauce and cheese are delicious. In my opinion this is the best upsidedown slice that I have reviewed. Better than spomoni gardens. 9.3 They are known for there sicilan so I'm giving them an average of all three scores

Little salty, has its own flavor solid slice

The famous upside down slice from Alfie’s. Went into Richmond hill to try Danis pizza but came out with this gem. The Sicilian pie is layered: crust, mozz, sauce, another layer of sauce and then a hearty amount of Parm on top. I would ask for it well done so you get that extra crisp it needs on the crust but just overall flavor it knocks other pizza out of the park. Def worth the 20 min drive.

This is up there with Rosa’s and L&B. Sauce was amazing, as was the crispy crust. Has a nice tang and a nice crunch, while the middle is light. Love it!

One of the best.

Nothing special I don’t understand what the hype is about taste like school pizza

One of the best slices of pizza I ever had In queens

The house slice is the Sicilian and it’s 🔥!

Crispy crust. Old school pizza at its finest!

Upside down slice

Solid pizza, however known for sicilian and everybody knows the rules if you say you're the best we're going to review it