Alfonso's Family Trattoria & Gourmet Pizzeria

Good thin cheesy pizza. If you like pizza with a lot of cheese try it out.

A little bit soft under carriage. Fairly tasty. Not great, not awful.

A bit floppy and the sauce to cheese ratio was a bit off. Crust has a nice crunch-overall average pie. The upside down grandma pie was much better I would rate that a 7.2

Local place - plain pie was not cooked enough very floppy & sloppy. Sauce was tasty. Upside Grandma much better and we’ll cooked.

Not bad.

Solid spot!

Good football style pizza. Some flop but the sauce is really good.

Bit of a floppy fuck but great sauce, good crunch. Could eat half a pie of this with no problem.

Grease lightning but good. The old cozy tavern like ambiance made me think they would almost certainly dish out a thin bar pie. I was wrong. This was a surprise big pie and borderline a Sunday football pizza. The dough was perfect somewhere in between and the ambiance and meatball sundae app contributes to a plausible rating here.

Enough grease to make your soul glo and bow to the golden arcs but this ain’t no big mic. The crust tho is impressive light and airy with some crunch but the over cheesed and under sauced slice flops worst than Denny Hamlin. Could’ve used a little oregano to spice things up but these are confusing times. Great joint and staff tho, many fond memories years ago.

Me and my son together came up with the score . He loves how cheesy it is.

A little flop. Slight crunch. Very good tasting slice of pizza. Unfortunately it’s a little too greasy. Would be a higher score if less greasy.

Solid pie, good football pizza ask for it well done or there will be too much flip. Sauce on the sweeter side and cheese is not over powering

Went for the vodka pie...solid crust, sauce a bit under seasoned but perfect amount of cheese...no flop over all a great slice, would definitely go back for more

Cheesy as all hell

Standard greasy NY slice written all over it. Not bad. Sauce had some tang. Wish the crust wasn’t so soft.

What you expect from an Italian restaurant. The pizza is too oily and fell apart easily

Overall, good pizza, crunchy crust, good new jersey flop.