dan.schnoll7/9/22, 9:31 p.m.
Tldr: Remarkably mediocre pizza, with this review being saved by their Philly cheesesteaks. We ordered the half tray “world famous“ deep dish and it was beyond mediocre. I’ve had stadium pizza that gives this a run for its money. The cheese was very sticky and kept sticking to the roof of my mouth. The sauce tasted very bland, and the dough was easily the worst offender. It had that synthetic taste to it, like you just heated up a DiGiorno pie. They almost definitely use pre-made dough. The one saving grace of this review is actually the Philly cheesesteak. It had the perfect balance of meat, cheese, and peppers. I only wish they toasted the roll they put it on. Overall it’s not worth coming here for the pizza, and although we did not try the other slices, I’m not very motivated to come back and try them. So much for being made famous by The Office.
snutchy6/6/22, 4:06 p.m.
The American cheese on a pizza is a very new concept to me. This pizza is shaped like a rectangle, but it’s definitely not a hot circle of garbage either. A mistake plus a keleven gives this a 7.3
alexgross75/10/22, 1:15 a.m.
Went with the thick crust. Half pepperoni half sausage. Never had sausage like this. Thin long strips. Liked the pepperoni better. Wasn’t great and wasn’t bad. I’ll go to Kevin for the inspiration for the score. Was hovering between a high 6 and low 7. 6.9 nice. A mistake plus keleven gets you home by 7.
befri93/30/22, 4:47 p.m.
Great sauce but the cheese is really lacking. It's good but there are for sure better pizzas our there.
jeff.mcdowell13/14/22, 8:30 p.m.
If you can’t get Kevin’s chilli, while in the Electric City, this is the next best thing. I really like the American cheese added in. The square pizza is great.
jonathon.stack11/20/21, 8:52 p.m.
Boxed a little sloppy but that’s alright. Cheese is great. NOT the same as Pizza by Alfredo’s. Rookie score.
thomas.hern11/20/21, 8:47 p.m.
Alfredo’s Pizza Cafe is a must stop for Office fans. Good Old Forge style pizza. Unique.
garan.atherton10/24/21, 5:25 p.m.
Good crisp and good taste! Definitely the “Good pizza” like on the Office!
james.towns10/15/21, 5:03 p.m.
Good crisp on the crust but the old forge style with the American cheese brings it down, definitely a good stop and great hospitality.
dan.ciccone8/29/21, 5:44 p.m.
Really good pizza old Fordge style thick but fluffy good crunch on the crust what makes it is the cheese it’s like an American i believe, overall very good
george.edwards37/20/21, 5:38 p.m.
Old Forge style! Loads of American cheese! Crispy undercarriage sweet sauce. Be careful you don’t burn your face off!
jim.cardona5/17/21, 10:05 p.m.
Picked up as a par bake to help it keep which was a first for me (350 in for 11min did the trick), this is heavier on the cheese than a typical Scranton square but it’s a unique cheese blend for sure which gives it its character, nice crispy crust with no flop, 8.5 is right in line with the others like this (Samarios, Maronis, etc) even if it is a little different
sam9523/27/21, 4:45 p.m.
Had to try while traveling through Scranton because I’m a huge fan of “The Office”, but honestly it kind of tastes like a hot circle of garbage.
griffin_foll3/4/21, 4:56 p.m.
Doesn’t taste like pizza but still gas. Super nice crisp, dough tastes like fresh Italian bread and the American cheese melts perfectly. Shoutout The Office.
nick.devito12/26/20, 7:21 p.m.
I really like the cheese. Just your traditional old forge style pizza.