Alfredo's Pizza Cafe

Best tray in NEPA!

It's your typical old forge style. I ordered a round pizza as well very dry . If old forge style is your thing I would give it a try.

“Tray” is their best. Used to be better. They went through a time where they were stingy with cheese, much more “normal” today. Round is far below average, I do not recommend round at all-5.2

If you like creamy, sticky, cheese that sticks to your mouth and teeth, this pizza is for you. The sauce was good but you couldn't enjoy because you were trying to get the cheese out of your mouth. Possibly the worst pizza I've had.

The cyst is the best part of this pizza in my opinion. Almost a French bread texture. The cheese was a little much to be honest. Was very “cheesy” if that makes sense. Atmosphere of the place was good and service was great. Definitely worth it if you’re an office fan

Cheesy in a not good way. Cheese sticks to the roof of your mouth like peanut butter. Crust and fluff was good. Go to Angelo’s in WB for a real good pizza.

Tastes better than it looks. HEAVY cheese. Most cheese on a pizza I’ve ever had - I guess it’s a regional thing. Couple pieces and you’re done.

I think Dave gave a generous score for this one. It really wasn’t that good. Staff seems annoyed if you mention a certain TV show.

So tried both their award winning thick and round thin. This is an Italian restaurant that also serves pizza. Nothing memorable.

This was a very misleading rating by Portnoy to say the least. American cheese? It’ll be stuck on the roof of my mouth for days to come. Sauce tastes like lunchables. Don’t get how there are that many awards on the walls. People of Scranton must not have tried pizza before

Alfredo’s Pizza Café (Not to be confused by, Pizza by Alfredo) was made famous by The Office. It was a pretty unique style of pizza, and is only common to North Eastern PA. The crust was thick, but still super light with good crisp, the sauce was solid and was super fresh. The cheese was a multiple blend, but the melted American seemed to be the most prominent. It was a solid place to go to if you’re an Office fan, but I’m not sure if it’s worth it if you’re not a fan of the show.

Flop: 3 Cheese: 10 Crust: 5 Hold: 4 Sauce: 8 +1 because it does The Office justice.

Light and crisp. Good but not great. Could use more flavor in the sauce

This the worst pizza on the planet. I’d literally rather have pizza from 7/11. I don’t think this represents the “old forge” style pizza properly, it really cheap at $14.00 but save your $14 for a Pizza Hut pizza. And the “cheese steak” was just nasty, they forgot all of my instructions. The office is a lie, and if you think this is good pizza you need Jesus.

Very good old forge style pizza. Service was excellent.

Tldr: Remarkably mediocre pizza, with this review being saved by their Philly cheesesteaks. We ordered the half tray “world famous“ deep dish and it was beyond mediocre. I’ve had stadium pizza that gives this a run for its money. The cheese was very sticky and kept sticking to the roof of my mouth. The sauce tasted very bland, and the dough was easily the worst offender. It had that synthetic taste to it, like you just heated up a DiGiorno pie. They almost definitely use pre-made dough. The one saving grace of this review is actually the Philly cheesesteak. It had the perfect balance of meat, cheese, and peppers. I only wish they toasted the roll they put it on. Overall it’s not worth coming here for the pizza, and although we did not try the other slices, I’m not very motivated to come back and try them. So much for being made famous by The Office.

The American cheese on a pizza is a very new concept to me. This pizza is shaped like a rectangle, but it’s definitely not a hot circle of garbage either. A mistake plus a keleven gives this a 7.3