All Star Pizza - Penfield NY

Ok, nothing special

The crust is charred and crisp, definitely has that homemade feel to it. Thr sauce is solid not like some of these shops that pour sugar in their sauce. It has real authentic tomato sauce flavor. Reasons i wouldn’t score higher 1.) They put parm on their slices. 2.) The pizza was slightly greasy but more because of the pepperoni. I would definitely come back here for a slice.

Average pizza

Thinner style pizza. No great flavor hits me while eating. It’s middle of the road pizza.

nothing to complain about but nothing special. solid za

Average pizza. Kind of messy

Needs to be less greasy. Solid pizza otherwise.

Very greasy, no crunch and a lot of flop. Sauce has decent taste.

My go to pizza in Rochester. Solid New York Style, cooked perfectly, and the cheese and sauce complement the pizza perfectly. Not to mention their wings are great.

Quick easy football pizza New York Style. Round up the boys we got Pie on the way!

Very soggy very greasy