I did a second review because they’re under new ownership and I’m convinced the pizza isn’t the same and neither is the experience. It’s no longer a hole in the wall, it now has an annoying chain restaurant feeling to it. They say the staff is the same but I only recognize one person. The pizza is thinner and greasier and clearly not as good as before. I now dub Vintage Pizza as best pizza in Manchester.
carter.chouinard1/17/21, 11:48 p.m.
Got some alright flip. Not a lot of grease which is a good thing. Very good pizza with good sauce. Crust could be better a little burnt but not bad. Overall a really good slice of pizza
chris.pacia10/25/20, 12:23 a.m.
Very good as football pizza. Thin and light. Reminiscent of New York street pizza. Could have been cooked a little longer. Not great but better than most places in New Hampshire.
bigmikepizzareviews6/19/20, 10:27 p.m.
Best pizza in Manchester, good crisp, good thin crust, good cheese, not greasy
spicybigpizzadaddy2/28/20, 5:41 p.m.
I risked getting a 500 dollar parking ticket for this slice. That being said, they advertise this as authentic New York style pizza. If that was the case there would’ve been a homeless man trying to sell me a mixed tape of ripped off Travis Scott raps. Overall, good cheese, sauce, and crust fam.
stephen.denis2/15/20, 12:02 a.m.
Great tasting combination of sauce and cheese. Asked for mine well done and it still came super doughy. A better crisp brings it closer to an 8. Probably the best football slice I've had in Manchester.
lailalikespizza8/25/19, 7:47 p.m.
Decent but nothing special. Asked for well done and still undercooked crust and floppy. Bland sauce but cheese made up for it.
nick.lacroix7/3/19, 12:20 a.m.
Very good pizza. Slightly undercooked I like a little crisp on the bottom.
regularmike5/20/19, 12:02 a.m.
I don’t know what happened here... this used to be the best pizza around for the longest time. I haven’t had it in a few years, and now it’s totally different. Flavorless, dough too thick. This review hurts me.
dane.levis4/17/19, 3:45 p.m.
Possibly the best slice in the city. A little over $2 for a slice. Sauce is great. Crispy and cheesy.
seth.lemieux9/9/18, 7:18 p.m.
Good cheese Good sauce Needs more crisp on the crust Overall decent slice
semir.hasanovic9/9/18, 5:30 p.m.
Nice Manchester flop. Golden brown crust. Terrific. Definitely a must try for Stooly’s !!