Regular slice was very good, although I asked for it “not too hot” and got it roof-of-the-mouth-scorching-hot. Sicilian was just average, and reminded me of pizza you’d get at an amusement park or somewhere you don’t expect it to be good.
michael.carroll61/9/21, 6:02 p.m.
Slamming good pie! I drove down from catskill ny to try out mike amalfis pizza. Great dude and super nice place. I recommend big time! It's my new go to spot when I'm in glen head!
chris.janusas4/7/20, 11:39 p.m.
This thick football-style pizza has a lot of bread, sauce and cheese, and the ingredients are all rationed perfectly. The cheese definitely has the most noticable taste on this generously sized pie. Definitely a great family shared or party sized pie.
keith.uhl7/31/19, 10:06 p.m.
First I’ll say it was delivered so not very hot, but we called at 445 and I had it in my hand 510, good timing. The pizza was good, nice dough, no wasted air in it, nice flavor, sauce was good with no extra kick which my wife liked. I can’t put a name on the sauce but it was good. I said sweet and my wife said no. I trust her. Overall one of the better pizzas.
steven.frank3/3/19, 1:19 a.m.
regular slice was half decent at best and the grandma slice was below average. no shot on an 8.
matt.nars10/4/18, 5:45 p.m.
High quality slice!!! Perfect crisp, great crust and cheese. Would love to put this in the 9 range but it was just a little too dry, needed more sauce. Overall very good!