American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream

Large pepperoni and cheese came in at $21.The crust was the best part but the bottom was super flimsy even when folded. The cheese and sauce were decent but the grease was excessive. I'm giving this one a 6 due to the greaziness and lack of a structurally sound bottom.

No crisp on pizza overall a decent slice. Friendly staff!!!

Was good for being in a beach area 10 hrs from the good NY pizza I am used to. Overall, good flavor. A bit greasy. I personally like a little thinner crust, cooked a bit more. If the left in over a few more minutes, would score higher. If thicker pie, doughy crust is your thing you will be very happy

Garlic crust is a plus.. Not crispy. Decent taste,not enough sauce and only an ok amount of cheese.. Served the purpose of beach pizza

Solid slice. I would get this again. Wish the crust was more crisp, but good pizza nonetheless.

Literally the oil is pizza I have ever had to date. The benchwarmer of Killdevil Hills has exposed itself. The KDH prince of pizza has spoken.

Stop number 1 in outer banks

Solid slice for lunch. Bit heavy, cheesy, has a little garlicy twang to the crust. Would be an A for cold weather football pizza.