American Pie Pizzeria

Can get a slice and do your Amazon returns at staples all at once!

Phenomenal grandma slice!! Vodka sauce slice was perfectly crispy on the bottom but found it a bit too cheesy, would’ve preferred more sauce.

Good undercarriage. Cheese a bit greasy, but good. Sauce is nice as well, but could use a bit more.

Bonus points for the girth of the Buffalo Chicken. The original cheese was also of the highest quality. #ColdBeach

Floppy greasy not a lot of flavor.

Really lackluster. Wouldn't even suggest as a drink pizza. Dough is tough and dense and doesn't taste like risen dough.

Decent slice lots of flop ok crisp lots of oil

Decent slice, shot in the dark pizza... some bites are very good, while other are sub par.

Lots of flop and little crust. Good sauce solid slice. Similar to a one dollar slice in nyc.

Good solid pizza. Good crunch, tasty sauce. Crust at the top was a little dry but other than that very good pizza

All the way in Sag Harbor, super greasy, but not bad for this area. 5.3 nothing compared to what I ate in NYC and CT. 5.3 that's a review

Terrible pizza specialty slice are meh and the stacked the slices on top of each other in the bag. Will not be coming back

Very dank