Amici's Pizza Cafe

Pizza is fantastic. Friendly owner and staff. Hidden gem.

Had the lunch special. Very solid slice overall. like the crisp and wasn’t much flop. It was crispy throughout and undercarriage was well cooked. Would’ve scored it higher, however, it’s a little thick for my liking, and as it I got closer to the crust, it was a tad doughy. Would’ve also liked a little more cheese to go with the sauce. Overall, a very well done slice.

Been coming here for over 15 years! Pizza is amazing! No flop/crispy bite and always consistent! Craig the owner is here every day working the grind ensuring they are serving up the best Pizza in Coconut Creek!!

Something has Definitely changed about this pizza. Not what it use to be. Disappointed

Overall, the Family Meal Deal is deserving of a straight 8.0 - large cheese pizza, garlic sticks, baked ziti, and salad. The lava of cheese shifted while driving the 8.0 miles back home. A little less cheese, a little more of that sauce, and cooked “well done” could take this pizza to another level. A good family-owned local place. The service was hospitable and sweet. The added brownie was apropos and a nice touch. I’ll be back to try the upside down pie. 👏🍕(Bonus: Rangled Ranch score of 4.0 out of 5.0 for those pizza bones)

My absolute favorite in South Florida, and I've lived here for 48 years. I've tried a lot of pizza. New to this app though. The sauce is amazing. I get extra to put on top its so good.

The owner is a nice guy , gave me a slice on a plate no flop nice taste to the sauce and cheese not to greasy, Thicker crust which I like thin crust better but the taste of the Dough good. When I got home and tried the pizza out of the box still no flop same good taste just not as crispy as the slice because the steam from the box. Best one yet on this app solid 7.3

I love AMICI’S’

Very basic pizza lacking flavor

Little greasy but plenty of cheese and a nice sauce. Not as thin as I like it but it as crispy on every bite and the crust was a little thick. Overall it was a solid slice. The server Francesca was a 10 great personality and a pleasure to talk with! Not my neighborhood but I would definitely go back when I’m in the area.

I gave their normal cheese slice an 8.8, which probably should have been higher, but this Sicilian slice was lacking in a lot of areas......VERY dough heavy ( which is normal for a sicilian slice compared to a regular slice) but the dough to cheese/sauce ratio was very inconsistent. It needed a lot more cheese & sauce.