Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow

The menu indicates that this Pizza should have “no flop” but it was all flop. Their honesty isn’t much else wrong with this pizza. Flavor wise it’s a 9 but texture just not as good as it could be. This was a 7.9 8.1 type of pizza and I went with 8.1 because it is absolutely delicious. Football Pizza for sure.

Decent flavor but nothing that blew me away.

Yeah this pizza checked all the boxes for us. We had the Demarco, the Maui Wowy, and the Combination pizzas. The crust had zero flop and was chalked full of ingredients. We don’t live here but this would be a “go-to” for us if we lived in the area.

Not bad Not great! Loved the sauce but little - to - no cheese goes for a bland bite every so often and the crust is sooooo good and soft.

Hands down my favorite pizza joint. Every time I come to Tulsa I get it. This particular pie was a little under cooked in my opinion and there’s as a lack of sausage but the flavor is still the best I’ve ever had.

We enjoyed the Demarco. It was very good! It has a good crust and nice amount of sauce. However, at $29, it’s a bit over priced.

Great crunch !

Ordered the NY Street Slice Pie without any changes. Good char, great taste, huge pie. Definitely will get again next time I’m in town.

Delicious pies!

Great pizza, slight flop, we got multiple pizzas with toppings and they were consistent. The place has great ambiance but beware this is not cheap pies if you are trying to stay on budget some can go up to 30$.

Good crust and quality toppings, but too much grease.

Solid slice, huge flop and a bit greasy. Pepperoni was good, wood fired oven is a plus. Next time I’ll ask for extra crisp.

7.3 all day.

Great slice with a great atmosphere.