About Andrew's Pizza & Bakery
90 Yelp Reviews
bobbythebrewer2/5/22, 2:29 a.m.
Cheese slice was solid. Little bit of flop. A little doughy. Would have loved some more crisp. Pepperoni was suuper greasy. Cool spot to grab a pint and some bar pizza.
harlay10/30/21, 10:45 p.m.
First I had the the cheese slice and it was not great. The cheese tasted like refrigerator, the sauce was bland, and the crust was nothing special. I was going to give the place a 3, but the pepperoni slice saved the day for Andrew’s. The pepperoni very well could’ve masked some of the problems I mentioned earlier, but it overall tasted fresher. I’m going to assume the first slice was sitting out for a while. All in all solid pizza place for the west coast, even for this bitchy Long Islander.
stephanie.wood18/24/20, 1:08 a.m.
Flop city. I think ours was undercooked; had potential to be better if they made it crispier. Sauce is a little bland but not terrible.
adam.albelli1/19/20, 12:31 a.m.
Good, not great. Very thin, paper thin, huge flop. Sauce is average. Good not bad.
holden.ryan6/30/19, 8:48 p.m.
Decent Pizza, good crust, good seasoning, sauce not blown back by;great atmosphere and employees