First I had the the cheese slice and it was not great. The cheese tasted like refrigerator, the sauce was bland, and the crust was nothing special. I was going to give the place a 3, but the pepperoni slice saved the day for Andrew’s. The pepperoni very well could’ve masked some of the problems I mentioned earlier, but it overall tasted fresher. I’m going to assume the first slice was sitting out for a while.
All in all solid pizza place for the west coast, even for this bitchy Long Islander.