Andy's Pizza - Shaw

Very good pizza brother!

Having just come from NYC and having Joe’s in the village, this is a great slice, great undercarriage and crisp bite, sauce is just a little underwhelming cheese is decent.. definitely worth a stop if around the university or 9:30 club preshow!

The dough/crust, though satisfying, isn’t compatible with the other ingredients

This is a pizza that kept growing on me. Great crunch, but was originally underwhelmed by the flavor. But the more I ate, the more I liked it.

Psh

Disclaimer: I did get this pizza delivered so it was not right out of the oven. Nice thin crust pizza sauce cheese and pepperoni had great flavor. I would expect this pizza to be a couple points higher if I got it there. Traditional football pizza .

Crust has great chew and flavor. I love the dummies leaving reviews of pepperoni pies saying it's greasy. No shit. Cheese and Margarita are where it's at here. Top 2 NY slice in DC area

A little underwhelming, cheese and sauce both lacking any real zip. The dough was light and pretty tasty but in general it was a very average tasting pie

Fresh out the oven. Floppy and greasy as hell, but the crust was phenomenal. Light and airy. Great sauce to cheese ratio and the sauce was sweet and rich. Easy mid to low 8s and cooked longer.

Had high hopes as DC remains pretty desolate as far as an excellent cheese slice goes. Thinness approximates NYC well. But cheese and sauce are pretty mild in flavor. Overall solid, not bad, not 8’s great.

Best NYC style pizza in DC. Even better than a lot of places in NYC.

Firm crust, great sauce. Delicious.

Lots of flop and a little greasy but by far the best large pie I’ve had in DC.

Closest to Johns of Bleeker I’ve had in DC. Coal fired. No flop. Great Crust.