Angela's Pizzeria

Well here we are on a beautiful Sunday, heading out to fire Island, after an amazing Pelham win on Friday night, and a Tigers win on Saturday. Great weekend so far. And I figured I’d hit a pizza place on my way out. I was trying to limit it to once a week, but what can you do. Extra cardio to burn the calories. Now I have to say, the slices look pretty good. They look crispy, they look like they’re gonna be good. Let’s rock ‘n’ roll. And just as I thought, they’re very good. Football pizza all the way. Maybe a tad thick, but still very good. Great sauce to cheese ratio, great crisp, nice undercarriage, and zero flop. Definitely some good pizza here. Sunday pizza, hopefully we get a Jets win tomorrow night. Let’s rock.

Great sauce and crust, a lot of creative options. Didn’t get a cheese or pep as usual, but glad I tried different options.

Not sure this can be considered the same review as my others but they surely get style points. If your feeling extra saucy (literally) then your football sundays should go no further. This is an experience and even the regular slice portion had a good bite. I imagine the pizza on its own is good too but how can you not try this.

This used to be my favorite slice when it was the original owners. It’s just not the same. It’s not bad. They put too much sauce on the pie and as you can see in this picture a blind man could of cut this better. They have a lot of speciality slices which are awesome.

Leaving a higher score review as the community is way too low on this place. The pizza is great. Good crust, sweet sauce and the cheese is perfect.

Excellent reg slice lots of flavor and they make extra large slices I was stuffed only eating two. Great service & location

Angelas never disappoints

Incredible Specialty slices. Pizza with calamari is a plus. Incredible undercarriage. Quality mozzarella.

Delicious sauce and good ratio of ingredients Could be a tiny bit less doughy

Heavy.super greasy. Sauce on the sweet side. Not my style

Little thick and crispy for my taste. Garlic knots are good though.

Super fluffy

Nice Sicilian. Sweet sauce. On the greasy side. Two slices knock me out. Solid choice. Cash only, old school pizzeria.

Pizza tastes like my socks!!!

Decent slice. cheese was good temperature was perfect friendly staff

Some of the cheese was an odd color and possibly old. I didn’t finish eating it and threw it out. Hopefully that’s a rare occurrence. Considering I couldn’t even eat it, a 2.5 is a generous score.

What an absolute treat of a slice. A real heavy, filling pizza for you experienced pizzur eaters. If ya like cheese, ya like Angela’s.