New pizzeria #2 for 2021. Angeloni’s in Caldwell NJ. The pizza is HYPER thin bar style pizza that is very sauce forward. Reminds me of Quincy’s in West Orange from yearssss ago. The crust has a sense of Asiago to it, which is a pleasant conclusion to the slice. The price point is steep (17.95), but nonetheless it’s a good pie. Dave Portnoy giving this an 8.8 is too much though. I will give this an 8.0 Still a good pie, absolutely worth trying once in the West Essex area.
marc.keith4/22/21, 12:21 a.m.
I feel I’m usually on lint with El’presidente, not quite on this . 8.8?? Very good pizza , but 8.8? Not quite , too greasy and not much cheese. Too thinny thin. Very good pie, but not 8.8.
dripboydan4/17/21, 5:18 a.m.
Got the small thinny thin , Good pie really thin and could taste the sauce , ate a whole pie alone so def small
youhadmeatpizza3/8/21, 5:04 p.m.
Really good pizza. Loved the thinness and cheese all the way to the edges. Needed a bit more tang in my opinion.
brian_f3/6/21, 5:14 p.m.
A good pie, with a good crust and okay sauce. Definitely eat inside as they give you free garlic knots!!
daveturner3/5/21, 1:30 a.m.
Updated review, original review I posted where I had 2 cold slices that sat in the car for an hour. Tonight my son and I ordered a fresh thin style pizza. The sauce puts the pizza in the 8’s. Sauce to cheese ratio spot on, good flavor on the crust. Only improvement would be to eliminate the edge parmigiano crisp (I can see how many would like the crisp, but not for me).
tim.kindt2/27/21, 5:24 p.m.
8.8 is a spot on. Great sauce, great cheese. Love the crunchy cheese crust. Get the thinny thin!!
brittany.crevier2/24/21, 11:34 p.m.
Hands down the best. Thin like paper crispy as hell. Flavor unimaginable 🍕
pete.rinaldi2/24/21, 5:16 p.m.
Unbelievable people and unbelievable pizza! Tasted so fresh. The sauce is delicious and the Thinny Thin is a MUST-HAVE!!! Thanks, Mike, Nicky and crew!!!!
homaam.dalko2/23/21, 8:09 p.m.
Awesome place, a must try if in the area. The thinny thin is a must have. The place has a great ambiance and the servers and owners are extremely nice
nickyboy.conforti2/23/21, 6:13 p.m.
The famous Thinny Thin crispy on the bottom crispy cheese to the end the tastiest pizza ever New Jersey’s best
dougie.dickman2/21/21, 4:57 p.m.
We tried the famous thinny thin. It was very unique but delicious. The crust was cheese it had a Parmesan crisp feel and taste. The sauce and cheese were both high quality and the pizza was really good overall. Highly deserved this score.
jason.borrelli2/16/21, 3:39 a.m.
David I have never been to New Haven but this is the holy f’n grail of bar pie’s. Portnoy DID NOT have the “Thinny Thin”. I seriously think he has to go back and try it. It was unbelievable a must try!!!