Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

One bite everybody knows the rules great pie, the best pepperoni and sauce I’ve had so far, the crust was thin and crispy just a bit too crispy for me. That’s the only thing that takes away from this fabulous pizza, it’s a” tell all your friends pie” that’s a review.

nyc angelo's is 🔥. reminds me of patsy's

I’m from Seattle and would hop on an airplane just to come back here for the pizza. I’m yet to try anything better

Great pizza, ignorant staff.

Meh. Not sure why this is rated so high. Average at best. This was supposed to be a margherita pizza. Dave dropped the ball on this one. Crust is good.

Average…definitely wouldn’t go out of my way for this

My son & I were in search of the best pizza in New York. We look a Dave’s highest rated places in NYC & picked Angelo’s. This was the best pizza I think I have ever had and I’m from Chicago & love Chicago style pizza! The sauce was delicious, the crust was nice and flaky. If you are in New York, specifically near Central Park stop here & try it!

Delicious. Great crust, good sauce, everything on point.

Nice crisp base and tasted great

Very solid pizza - sauce is fantastic and just the right amount of cheese. Crust was very good - if it were a little crispier the score would have been even higher.

Real stinkin good

Great one! Good crust, a lot of drip, great tomato sauce and cheese!

Great crust with no flop. Good balance of sauce & cheese. Cooked to perfection. A little more tang in the sauce than I prefer but still tastes great.

Best pizza I’ve ever had! Glad I got to have lunch here while in the city for the weekend.

It was a solid pizza with a slight New York flop. Definitely worth a try.

Truly exceptional pizza. The coal fired oven has got to be more than 100 years old.

Ordered two 13” - 1 house, 1 arugula & prosciutto. Sauce and crust were amazing!! Only complaint is they were a little skimpy on the prosciutto distribution - some slices had none at all. Great environment & waiter had heavy Italian accent :)

Angelo’s Coal Oven Pizzeria! This pizza was absolutely spectacular. As soon as it hit the table, I knew this was going to be special. The first bite was incredible…loaded with flavor. The sauce is fantastic. Beautiful combination of sweet and spicy and it was present in every bite. There was a perfect amount of cheese as well. Super flavorful and most importantly to me, there wasn’t too much of it. The pepperoni was super high quality and really enhanced the eating experience. The crunch was perfect. Solid undercarriage with zero flop. The pie came out within 10 minutes of ordering it. This is hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. It’s cracked my personal top 4 list. If you’re in NYC, this is a MUST try!