Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

Such good pizza. The cheese and pep was as Dave said but my sausage and olive was a little flimsy in the center. Could use a little more sauce. So damn good!

One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Perfect amount of sauce and tang, good flop and a nice crunch as well. Nice blend of cheese and spices to top it off.

The pepperoni was thick and perfectly cuppy, mozzarella was fresh, crust was chewy and crisp

Nice crust solid sauce

Solid undercarriage, phenomenal sauce. NYC pie at its finest

Unbelievable. Loss of words

It was soooo good! 7/24 at lunch

The sauce was tasty the crust was amazing but overall the slice felt a bit dry

no doubt the best pizza in the country. i’ve tried it all from the best in new haven to chicago to nyc. this reigns king

Good pizza but I did think the crust was a little to charred or baked. But the balance between sauce, cheese and crust was well balanced. I’ll give them another shot again in the future.

Solid pizza and cool atmosphere.

Needed more cheese and was a bit too crunchy for me

Excellent pizza.

Very good. Crust wasn’t too thick and it was coal fired so nice and crisp throughout which was really nice and left a fried crispyness flavor. Not chewy like Neapolitan but still good. Lot of bright sauce with basil which was nice and well proportioned cheese, but the sauce and cheese flavor was not quite as good as a great Neapolitan would be.

Great sauce. Nice crispy. Fresh basil on all pies. I prefer sauce a cheese a little closer to the edge. Calamari was excellent.

What can I say? A true generational talent here. Every ingredient might be the best I’ve ever had in a pizza, but the pepperonis truly set this thing apart. Small, crispy; they’re perfect. Not a 10 out of principle, but it’s basically a perfect pie.

No wonder Dave’s top 2 are so close. Went to Johns of Bleecker yesterday and it was amazing. Didn’t think I’d find a pie that tops it but my goodness I did. Coal fired to perfection. Sauce is amazing. Perfect cheese ratio and slight flop. No disrespect to Johns of Bleecker (it was amazing too) but this is now the best pizza I’ve ever had. As Luke Bryan said “if you ain’t a 10 you’re a 9.9”

Very good ingredients. Low flop. Excellent sauce and dough. Highly recommend!

The sauce was amazing but just needed a tinge more tang and undercarriage could’ve been a little more firm but that’s neither here or there - an amazing pizza!

Amazing crust, good crisp, amazing sauce and flavor of the whole pie. The mozzarella splotches make it all come together, best pizza i’ve ever eaten.