Definitely the best pizza I’ve had. Great sauce, cheese, crust was of my ideal thickness. Fresh basil always a nice touch. Had Johns of Bleeker the day prior and the sauce and cheese gives Angelos the edge in my opinion. Both were more flavorful and the sauce a bit sweeter.
joe.seher11/24/20, 6:05 p.m.
If you are in NYC you MUST STOP! 9.5 Margarita pie. Tremendous sauce, cheese was excellent. Very very nice place and people
ryanloewy11/21/20, 5:21 p.m.
Marinara is excellent. Good balance of crisp and dough but wish there was a bit more crisp. Phenomenal pizza nonetheless. That’s a review Franklyn!!!
megan.gartner11/14/20, 10:30 p.m.
Excellent pizza the crust was good the mozzarella was fresh tasted amazing highly recommend if you are in the area
elyseparker11/13/20, 7:57 p.m.
Very light, crunchy, and has great texture. Sauce is very tasty and cheese is good quality.
pizzamuckpete11/8/20, 6:57 p.m.
This is why we do it. Dynamite sauce. Perfect crust. Need more of this
d.s6510/19/20, 6:06 p.m.
I am clearly not a food photog...but a 30 yr NYer & just found this place. Wow! I could drink a pint of this sauce. Amazing pizza!
doug-abby-pizza-review10/13/20, 1:13 a.m.
Sauce and cheese were delicious. A bit doughy, not as much crunch as you’d expect from a coal fired pie but still very delicious.
tread4210/9/20, 4:54 p.m.
Great pizza next door to The Late Show studios on 57th St. coal fired oven produces awesome results.
18 views•1 like
mike.mcnamee10/8/20, 12:32 a.m.
Delicious pumpkin pizza !! Charred crust from wood burning oven !! How's perfect with a Caberet
pizza_reviews_on_the_go9/30/20, 10:25 a.m.
It was excellent...but didn’t have the overall flavor of a John’s of Bleecker pie or Pepe’s. It was crispier though! The crispiest Coal Oven Pizza ever! Cheese was too ordinary to be out into the 9’s
jgearhart339/20/20, 11:02 p.m.
The cheese pizza was fantastic, sauce and basil was great. The sausage was over powering. The 8.7 is based solely on the cheese slice.
kevin.price9/14/20, 11:25 p.m.
Finally got uptown to this place and it shook my hand and told me I was gonna like it. Ingredients absolutely on point fresh af cooked dead on. Got up close with the oven and talked to maybe Angelo himself great people and a must return. On a Lucali level the perfect proportion and flavor make for a epic pie and make monday feel like a bumped up Friday. Dave knows what I’m sayin!
zack.maroon9/6/20, 2:31 a.m.
Perfectly cooked with incredible crust. All around excellent pizza. Great sauce and cheese. Perfect pepperoni.
harrison.glassman8/31/20, 12:24 a.m.
8.2——Excellent pizza. All the ingredients come together to make a very hearty and satisfying slice. The sauce is great and very tangy (would prefer less salt and a little more sweetness though). The basil flavor shines without overpowering the other ingredients. Slight coal flavor in the dough is nice, but it could be more pronounced. A saltier dough would also add more flavor. Lastly, I liked the cheese, but there was a bit too much and not enough sauce. The mozzarella was perhaps a little bland, and there was a strong Parmesan flavor in there (which I felt was a bit too strong). Overall though, it’s a very fresh and flavorful pie, and it was very enjoyable.