Angelo's Pizza

Extremely good pizza! Dough cooked perfectly with a nice pull to it. Sauce is tasty with a unique flavor. Fresh made mozzarella also but the star of this pizza is the thick cut uncured pepperoni.

Just enough flop, love the cheese, wood fired

Wonders! Coal fired deliciousness. Sauce is perfect! A little more cheese maybe. Would drive an hour for this pizza

Good pizza. Good tang. Little flop. Wanted it to have more of a crunch

Tangy sauce, salty cheese, good undercarriage. One step at a time.

Decent pizza, I was surprised by the lack of taste the pizza had. I wish it was a little more garlicy and had more parm on top.

Best pizza ever?

Good pie. Cheese is the focal point here. Good crust and sauce but the cheese is front and center. My style of pizza with the thin coal oven crust but didn't push the envelope too much.

Best pizza I’ve ever had. This was the 57th St location. The sauce was out of this world good. Didn’t know a cheese pizza could have this much flavor

Excellent pizza. The sauce is very tasty

2 pretty small portion pizzas = 60 dollars when this place is not any better than your average 1$ pizza joint in NYC. Just not that good.

Far superior to the other Angelos Pizza and the top of the 7 coal spots in Manhattan for sure

Overall great pizza. Some pieces were better than the others but all around great flavorful sauce and crust.

We got catfishes and went to the wrong Angelos. Out of the ashes of disappointment rose a very good pizza. Overcame the initial sadness, which I thought would taint the score, but lots of sauce and fresh mozzarella with a perfect crust underlayment made this a very very good pie.