Angelo's Pizza

8.1 is the absolute correct score here. Really good Margarita pie. Great spot on 2nd Ave!!!

Floppy mess to begin with. Sooo much grease, no structural integrity to the slice at all, had to roll it up to attempt to eat it. After that, it made my stomach feel awful, which was a far worse experience than the actual pizza. 3.1 might be generous, but I feel like without the pepperoni it wouldn’t me as much of a greasy floppy mess.

This caught me off guard as being one of the best slices I’ve had in Manhattan over the last year. Absolutely phenomenal cheese and very good crust. I will certainly be coming back here.

Sauce and cheese is great. Crust a little burnt, solid pie

Best Neopolitan pie in NYC. Good crust, tasty sauce and the freshest toppings. If you don't like this, you don't like pizza.

Crisp crust and the sauce has a nice kick to it if it wasn’t delivered might bee a few points higher

Sweet sauce Neapolitan style pizza. Light thin crust with a good crisp. Pic is my pie in the oven.

sweet sauce.. love the thin crust (but I’m a thin crust person).. not enough cheese for me personally.. overall good but nothing outstanding

Lots of sauce and it’s the clear highlight of this pizza. Cheese is also very fresh. Crust was a bit of a disappointment - it was crunchy but had a little staleness to it. Had a lot of crust leftover on my plate, which should never happen. Large portions though.

Sauce is light and sweet. Could use more cheese. Major lack of flop. Still good.

Always a solid slice at Angelo’s.