Angelotti's | Pizza • Trattoria

The plain slice was floppy, soupy and did not taste that great. On the other hand the grandma square was crispy and with much better flavor.

Haven't been here in 6 years. Upgrading score! Fresh pie much better than individual slices. Nice crispy thin crust.

Nice everyday football pizza. No flop, great crust.

Pizza is ok at best nothing special

Delicious Cheese hits you immediately on this traditional nyc slice. Thinner crust with a great crunch and limited flop. The Sauce takes a backseat as the other ingredients are better and more powerful.

Could be a little more well done but cheese has some good tang to it

Pizza was good. Sauce was good. Cheese was good. Crust was cooked well but pretty basic. Above average slice but missing a little something to get it into 7+ rating. If you are hungry and in the area, grab a slice.

“1 plain, not too crispy.” Standard flop on this thin & still chewy crust. Really greasy cause of a on of cheese but not crazy about it, or the bland sauce. I like my sauce tangy & this doesn’t do it for me. So greasy!

From the flavor to the structural integrity, Angelotti’s nails it in all departments. Definitely a MUST VISIT! Consider the bar raised

Absolutely delicious slice, crispy, no flop, no grease, fantastic sauce; well worth the 45 minute drive. Best pizza I have had in Jersey.

Awesome grandma slice fantastic taste

Good thin slice of pizza would of liked a little more sauce but overall a good slice.

Needs more sauce

Stumbled into this place on a whim, didn’t regret it. Good sauce, a little light on the cheese, no oil. Some flop good fold. If you bring this home as a football pizza, folks will definitely stay for the game. Not bad and will come back if in a pinch

Zero flop, and a nice fold. The dough cook perfect and crispy. The center of the slice was a little to thin and the sauce was coming through. The sauce was good and sweet. The cheese was fair and a bit oily. Overall it was a really good slice. I look forward to trying it again and hopefully I may be able to increase my score.

I said “gollop”, I meant “dollop.” Sue me. Good slice of 🍕.

Try the vodka slice. So good I forgot tot take the picture before eating it.