jesse.merdak9/13/21, 4:18 p.m.
Not bad, crust was good. Not really the NYC flavor though to me and I can’t put my finger on why. A lot of grease on my slice so maybe we just got the wrong slices. Maybe a little longer in the oven in would have helped it out. Overall, not bad, respectable bar pie.
cbakes8/24/21, 6:59 p.m.
got the girlfriends approval having had real Italian pizza. best pie I've had from here. minimal flop, great crispy crust and undercarriage. sauce and cheese is on point. FANTASTIC pie.
tonymonerojr5/17/21, 10:00 p.m.
As close to a Brooklyn local pizza shop I’ve found since leaving over 20 years ago.
tyler326012/6/20, 10:58 p.m.
Good crust. Very crispy (I did order it well done). Sauce lacked tang, and I was pretty greasy. Pretty good pizza.
jrzanyc9/4/20, 11:55 p.m.
OK kids, quarantine review time once again. This time on my way out of the finger Lakes. Where in Corning New York. Aniello’s Pizza. This place was packed to the gills. I’ve heard about it up in the finger Lakes because everyone was saying if you want to try real pizza that’s close to what you’re used to in New York City then come here. So here I am. I have to say throughout my reviews and the finger lakes I was highly disappointed. I know it’s not New York City but come on guys step your game up. I have to say this place did just that. other than burning my absolute face off it was one not to be missed. I was shocked and impressed. If you look at any of my reviews although I may try another slice just like Prez I only review the cheese slice. Just keeping it real. Maybe I just got lucky but I got a nice crisp slice, no flop, no grease, but unbelievably hot. Nice and well done just like I like it even the cheese got that little brown on the top. Real good flavor of the cheese my biggest knock would be the sauce. Aside from What burn my face off there could’ve been a little bit more. What shocked me the most was the Dough, it had a nice buttery almost cracker like taste on the bottom similar to Federici‘s in freehold New Jersey but definitely a thicker slice. I’ll be back (terminator voice) 8.4 that’s the review.... bonus time......The buffalo slice I had was the best buffalo slice I’ve ever had hands-down. That shocked me as well. Maybe it’s because I’m closer to Buffalo LOL
bhale1357/26/20, 3:45 p.m.
Not the best in the southern tier. Good pie blue cheese on it SMACKS your tits off. Recommended
49 views•4 likes
corey.roof7/13/20, 4:11 p.m.
Cheese is a lil different but the base was good and lil flop. Low on the grease.
jt.rice2/1/20, 6:47 p.m.
Lots of grease, mild flop. Great taste. Not a NY pizza guy but this great. My favorite NY slice thus far
95 views•1 like
derrdylan12/31/19, 4:07 a.m.
Just like old Mr. Aniello used to always say “if you don’t like my pizza, bafangool!”
ma022512/26/19, 9:32 p.m.
Best. Pizza. Ever. The cheese is unlike any one elses, the crust has the perfect crunch and the sauce has enough tang to tie it all together.
will.weimer11/30/19, 10:41 p.m.
Consistently soft doughy crust. Very flavorful red sauce with a hint of spice. Could eat a whole pie for sure.
nate.jurusik11/29/19, 10:23 p.m.
I’ve had pizza all over and nothing has compared to Aniello’s. Fresh sauce and cheese with perfect crust. The Pres needs to come here. Best pizza in NY and anywhere else as far as I’m concerned. Only place I would ever leave a perfect 10.
ryanmr19918/11/19, 5:57 p.m.
Great flavor with a nice NY flop. A little doughy though. 3 more minutes in the oven and it would have been perfect