Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Mid, hot honey slice was good tho

Pretty good pizza

Meh. Decent crust. Little flop. Sauce meh. Cheese meh. Little chew. Basic.

This may have been my first coal fired pizza. Crust was super crispy but the pizza still had some flop. The cheese and sauce were decent. Overall its a pizza that’s worth the stop. I really loved their chicken wings tho. Definitely get a few of those while you’re there too.

Well, as i do, I chased another coal fired pizza while I out of town. Anthony’s was ok, not the best, but not doing a disservice to the coal fired trade either. No flip, good char, good sauce, okay cheese. It was good, next time I’ll try another though. 7.5

Very good, but I suggest when ordering to ask for extra sauce, and cheese. Still a delicious pizza!

Very solid pizza with good flop and crunchy crust.

A lot of flop. Cheese and sauce is perfect. Best pizza in Long Island.

I don’t get the hate. Very little flop. Crust has tremendous crisp. If I’m getting coal fired pizza, this is where I go

If Fridays made a pizza chain this would be it. Went with a specialty pie because I saw the other reviews, it’s basically pita bread with Costco meatballs n a drop of sauce and cheese. Also overpriced

It’s the Applebee’s of the Pizza world. Just average.

Legit coal fired. Can’t order a slice, need to order the pie. Crispy, no quality ingredients. Fair, I’m rookie scoring this a solid 5.0

That’s an expensive pie, Frankie. Barely any sauce. Not a fan. Score would be lower, but there was absolutely zero flop.