Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Amazing pizza

I got a 12” pie at the bar. Great under carriage. Zero flop. Crispy crust. Great flavor. Would have been slightly higher but a couple slices were too charred on crust. Overall great pizza

Decent pizza for Long Island. Better than most I’ve had out here.

Excellent crust good tang to the sauce excellent cheese no grease

Honestly disappointing. Was expecting a better taste for the price. Pizza was hard and lacked flavor. Certainly not the worse in the area but for the price the pizza could have atleast been a bit larger....

Good pie. Nice thin and crispy crust. Sauce was really good, but not enough. Good ratio of cheese, and not greasy. 7.3 BONUS REVIEW: no Dr. Pepper. 0.0

Had half sausage half traditional, review for the traditional of course. Excellent thin crust with good char but no burnt taste, good crisp. Sauce was excellent and well balanced with cheese, not greasy at all. Loved it, highly recommend and will be back

Regular pepperoni pie.... the cheese, the sauce, the perfect toasted bread and crust. Place is a Winner!

Very good, not incredible hard pizza.

Good crust solid pizza