Well done as far as cooked. Good taste. Not hands down best, but, a good coal fire pizza.
u_wanna_pizza_me5/26/20, 2:20 a.m.
Aright Frankie...Anthony’s loaded it up with pepperoni, but besides that, the pizza left a lot to be desired. Just very doughy and not sauced or cheesed very well. Crust didn’t have the good crunch you’d expect with coal fired. One and done and this pie.
onemorebite11/16/19, 10:32 p.m.
I would expect more out of an establishment that makes the effort to cook in a coal fired environment. Nothing is fresh and crust is chewy.
deignasty6/13/19, 12:58 a.m.
Did not get the gold standard but we got our go to ricotta and meatball. It’s not a bad pizza. Nice and crispy. With the toppings we got it does flop and you do lose toppings. But taking that out it is good. Sauce had good taste but had chunks of tomato which I don’t like. I give it a 6.8 and that’s a review
ocbeast6/8/19, 1:36 a.m.
Tried this pizza shop based on high scores...turns out they’re way too high! This is a coal fired pie. The crust was crisp with a nice coal fired finish. That’s prob best thing I can say about this pie. Not enough cheese and the sauce was chunky and not evenly dispersed. Dough was floury in some spots. Not too much flop. Very expensive for what you get. By far best part of experience were the wings, they’re actually really great! Prob would not go out of my way to get this pie again.
jason.kimmins5/22/19, 4:35 p.m.
As I sit here and score this pizza this place has an amazing score of 8.1 on the one bite app. Now I will shoot you straight and tell you that this pizza is not an 8.1 because I would not travel for this pie. The pizza has some crisp to it but the sauce is a bit bland. The cheese is decent but not spectacular. I think a 7.1 is more than a fair score.
justin.romer4/11/19, 12:57 a.m.
If you don’t like well done crust let them know, they will accommodate. Good tasting sauce-good cheese
nicolosi3/14/19, 11:55 p.m.
Half Paulie’s Pie (6.7) & half Eggplant Marino (7.1) for an average of 6.9. A little under cooked.
joseph.ficarrotta1/4/19, 3:11 a.m.
Pizza a little doughy. Not too crispy, not a lot of cheese, average pizza
pizzaking0911/6/18, 11:17 p.m.
Fucking great fuckin pizza! Quality ingredients, chunky, sweet sauce, thin and tasty crust and deliciously, proportionate cheese. You gotta give Anthony’s a try. 8.1 is a review.
dieselpizza9/23/18, 9:24 p.m.
First off the coal fired wings here are unbelievable. The pizza, great taste, nice thin but chewy crust, no flop, almost no grease, sweeter sauce but nice balance, cheese is great. Really good pizza. The wings are amazing.