Anthony's Italian Kitchen

Super thin, nice char, great crust. Wish the sauce had a little zip to it, it’s pretty basic. All around excellent pie though. Very cool decor and atmosphere.

Tough to rate accurately since it came from the slice window so who knows how long it had been sitting there but the flavor was good.

Good pizza. Taste was great - sauce, cheese, seasoning - very nice (Borat voice). Cool little spot too. Could’ve definitely been low, maybe even mid 7’s if it wasn’t for the complete lack of crisp. Wouldn’t say it was overly floppy but it was very soft and chewy

Anthony's is tucked away in the basement of another storefront, and if you blinked you'd miss it.  Grabbed a slice of cheese after seeing the high rating on the One Bite App, and while the slice wasn't bad by any means, I'm guessing a few of those reviews were either staff of friends/family of staff, because there is no way on Earth this place deserves in the high 8's.  Reminded me of an upscale Costco slice, with tons and I mean TONS of Portland flop on this slice, to go along with a decent amount of grease.  With that said, the flavor alone was good enough to get it into the 6's!  

Hidden gem in Portlands Old Port for 30 years. Fantastic tasting sauce and a cool space.

Tasty sauce

Sauce is good, cheese not bad, floppy and some what greasy.

It's like Costco opened a pizza store and threw in some asiago

Grease!

Incredible, if you like a good amount of sightly chewy dough and cheese.