Unimpressed. We ordered the Margherita pie and it was a cheese slice topped with a few dabs of mozzarella. Also it was lacking basil. Dough has zero flavor.
outfishing8/14/20, 10:31 p.m.
Way to much flop and the crust is too floppy. Good for St. Aug pizza.
surfeatsleep6/26/20, 10:07 p.m.
Margherita Pizza. Ordered well done. Super floppy. No Crisp. Good sauce. More cheese pizza than margherita.
spiceymeatballs12/3/19, 11:52 p.m.
On a road trip and passed by Anthony’s, we were told a former New Yorker was the owner. Very good service, little flop, good solid slice. We also ordered eggplant,chicken and meatball parmigiana sandwich... excellent
garebear10/27/19, 9:34 p.m.
Alright, Kyle..... Anthony's Pizza, A1A Beach St Augustine..... margherita pie.. one bite , everybody knows the rules. No flop....looks great.... great crisp... the sauce is actually chunky, you can tell it's homemade, not out of a can....not tangy but great flavor... little sloppy with toppings sliding off in the box But actually a great pizza. Shocked to find this quality in my own back yard. 8.2 and that's a review
mac.mattingly7/1/19, 6:25 p.m.
A little bland in the sauce department. Nice crust but it’s missing some flavor