Anthony's Pizzeria

Zero flop, great crisp on the crust. Sauce and cheese had a great flavor. Maybe add a few more pepperoni? Enjoyed this pie and will return. We have a winner here spider!

Pepperoni solid 7.6 / 10 - very greasy. Buffalo Chicken 8/10.

Pretty good, but inconsistent pizza here. The first slice was fantastic and could’ve been in the lower 8s with good cheese, fresh sauce with a good crispy and charred crust… However the second slice was mid 6s at best… crust was too burnt, which over powered the cheese and there was nowhere near enough sauce. Evens out to a 7.6

Probably my favorite slice out there. Right next to capital University’s campus, Anthony’s is a great place to grab a bite to eat and sit outside with your friends and family. May not be the perfect slice in looks but the absolute best in taste.

Decent deep dish pizza. Very heavy and doughy. Sauce was good, lots of pepperoni, and decent amount of flop. Solid 7/10.

Undercooked, dough falls apart when you pick it up, not a great taste

I think this could have been better. It was just made terribly and not cooked well as you can see. Unfortunate.

Horrible sauce crust was good and there deep crust was the worst thing ever under cooked

Good bite, crispy, over very good pie

Too much dough and not enough sauce but it had a solid crisp

Enjoyable, but deep dish crust is too “doughy” for me.

A light, delicious slice with a fair amount of time Columbus flop. I'd eat this 7 days a week.

The Dr at it again!