Antico Pizza

Here’s the thing….I had high expectations of this spot. I really wanted to love this joint. Cool ovens in the back, awesome Italian style atmosphere, kick ass back patio that makes me want to drink Peroni all day. Pizza fell short. Sauce need more salt, I was not happy with the small amount of basil and cheese. The crust saved it for me though. Although not the best crisp, it was there. Very consistent crust all the way around. Again, I wanted to love this joint but it just feel short today.

Arguably the best pizza in ATL. This isn't football pizza tho, definitely a more expensive date night type pizza. However, the quality, overall flavor, and crust puts this into the 9's for me. I could see if this wasn't your style (or price) that it may be ranked lower for some, but anyone who knows pizza should have this at minimum a 7+ score.

Too much flop. Wish it had more cheese

Absolute fire!!! Very fresh. Wish it was less floppy. Will travel 700 miles agin for it.

Best pizza in Georgia, hands down! Wood fired, crispy crust, excellent flavor and fresh ingredients. Plus the ambiance is very cool! Highly recommend.

Quality fresh ingredients! Very floppy. If you eat it ALL within minutes of purchase it’s a mid 8... but once it gets a little room-temp it’s not very good. Fresh=Love. Room-temp=wouldn’t have a second slice. 7.6 good middle ground. Also a pain in the ass to get to unless you live on that side of ATL. Could not do carry out, have to eat there. $21+ is a bit steep too.

Amazing taste and veteran move on putting a hole in the box so it keeps its crisp. One of the top 3 pizzas I’ve had!

Great sauce. A bit floppy. Good ingredients.

Cheese is great. Nice edge.

Pretty Solid Place! Little busy but not too much. Pizza comes out at a decent pace

Been coming here for a long time, almost never disappoints. Do yourself a favor and order the Marinara. It usually gets ordered on accident, so they will probably ask if you’re sure you want a pizza without cheese and with Anchovies… but these are the usual salty canned fillets… throw some raw garlic and enjoy a taste Napoli. Excellent undercarriage on this one tonight… simply the best and my absolute favorite in the country!

Great dough, but a little greasy and a little floppy

Definitely lives up to the hype. Great pie!

Fast service. Nice flop. Minimal oil. Fluffy crust. Medium char.

Loved it. Will say, tasted so good I could look past the flopage, but the flopage held rating under 9.

I was between a 7.9 and an 8.1 but I would 100% drive for this pizza. You can tell it’s all fresh ingredients and that’s what really sets it apart from other pizzas I’ve had In Atlanta. Very very good!

Great Pizza, too much flop to it though. If it was crisper then it would be in the 9s.

Best of the best

A near perfect Margherita pizza. Cheese was excellent, sauce was excellent, dough had great flavor and chew, and the pizzas was cooked just right. A little bit of flop at the tip from the sauce to mozzarella ratio, but that’s to be expected from a Neapolitan pizza. Overall amazing pizza, and worth the drive.

Diavola

Prior to Antico I’ve never had Neapolitan pizza before. However, after coming to Antico I can quite literally say it’s my favorite style. Very light pizza, tremendous cheese, nice bite of the crust and sauce is as good as it gets.

Fresh and quality ingredients. Incredible crust with a Neopolitan char. One for the ages.