Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks

Crust is a high 8 with great crisp and chew. Cheese and sauce was a little scarce. This would be a solid 8 with more sauce and cheese.

Absolutely legendary crisp. Unparalleled undercarriage. Would like to see a little more cheese and sauce but very pleased overall.

Slightly burned. Decent sauce on the grandma.

Very basic looking football pie, but definitely one of the better ones! Favorite part was the crust, it was like taking a bite out of a French baguette. One of the better college pizza places in the country.

Cheese slice

Tim 7.6 Charlie 7.9

Solid pizza, not greasy, nice crisp on the crust, a little flop and taste good, definitely some of the better pizza in the orlando area!

regular cheese slice was good, nothing special, but good. the sicilian slice was better than the normal slice in my opinion, i’d give the sicilian a 7.7. overall a good spot.

It’s very ok. Nothing amazed me about but it’s solid pizza. Not too greasy. Not the undercarriage with that blackened and not a ton of flop. I will probably go back when I’m craving pizza, but not great. Much better than park ave pizza.

Thin crust, little sauce, not much here to review.

Good crisp, tasty thin crust. Ok floppage and not too greasy. Sauce needs a bit more spice and volume.

A step above the other pizzerias in the area

Very good pizza. Thickness, cheese and sauce are very good. Also got eggplant and meatball subs which were very good

Gave Antonella's a try for slices after they popped up on a previous discussion. Decent slice. A bit smaller than average and a little pricier. $3 a slice. Good crust and crisp bottom. Good tasting sauce and cheese. Did not crack my top 5 in central Florida but better than the new place in Oviedo most everyone raves about. Would go back if in the area but wouldn't go out of my way for it.

Thin crust was good, could use a little more sauce. Cheese was fine. Pepperoni added a bit of drip. Might have the pie cooked a little well done next time. Just preference. Overall a 6.9.

Ordered a margarita pizza. Reviews on here were pretty positive. This is a decent Florida pizza, but these Floridians are a little too generous with their scores. Crust could use some more flavor, but overall this will be fine for dinner. If this was in NY it would be out of business in a week, here in Florida I assume it will enjoy decades of success.

Good crust overall mediocre slice

Little flop, not too greasy, crust needs salt

Woah

Closet pizza to new york. Best in orlando