Antonio's Real New York Pizza

Thing burnt my face off. Real good slice. Good crust, good cheese, just a little salty. Not the best pizza in Colorado as they claim, Redeemer still holds that crown.

Fabulous pizza in Estes Park. Didn’t do the cheese only. Maybe next time.

Did order the NY cheese well done, so some may say we cheated, but 8.5 may be low. Maybe it’s the robot that lowered my score a pinch haha

Crazy how solid this pie is, good crunch, no flop, but not extremely heavy for a Sicilian. Every type of pie imaginable here from Grandma to Detroit. I’m sure it’s all good, but Sicilian is my favorite. This is a place you travel to eat it, putting it into the 8’s

Pretty amazing that there is decent pizza place in the middle of the Rocky Mountains. Impressed by the crunchyness for the 26" size. Not doughy.

Favorite place to eat pizza in Colorado

If it weren't for the unexpected flop, this would have been a much higher score. Great flavor and the edges are very crisp. For true NYC it should probably be thinner too.

Wonderful pizza. Crisp crust. Tasty, well cooked cheese. Could have had a few more pepperonis - but an amazing pie. That or I was bad hungry from the hiking.

Great authentic NY style, solid undercarriage overall pretty good for the mountains.

This is considered "thin" but I'd compare it more to hand tossed. Amazing crust, sauce, and cheese. One of the better pies I've had. Worthy of being in the 9's imo. I feel the current overall avg is low at 7.9.

Crust is heavenly and very light but if your a sauce lover make sure to order extra

New career high, very tasty.

We got an NY and Sicilian and both were awesome! Great NY style pizza! We rated the Sicilian 8.3 and the NY 7.9 so it evened out to 8.1. Love this place!

We did the thick and thin crust. Both were very good. This seems to be and Italian family’s restaurant as all the workers look to be Italian. Awesome location and unexpected for heading into RMNP

Damn good NY style pizza.

Pepperonis are really good. Good sauce. Low flop. Pretty greasy

Nice crisp. Tasty cheese and sauce. If this was closer I'd eat here often.

Good pepperoni and good crust. Greasy

Crisp crust

Good crisp, good sauce, and good cheese to sauce ratio. No reason to go to anywhere else in Estes park.

Big flop. Sauce is a bit tangy. Good pizza