After a whirlwind pizza tour amongst all the city’s best (John’s of Bleeker, Rubirosa, etc etc), Apizza in New Paltz wins it all. I’m reluctant to even write this review because I feel quite lucky to be able to get a table any time I want in the restaurant. My suspicion is that this place will eventually be a perennial in the conversation with Sally’s, Pepe’s, John’s et all. Favorite pizza in all of NY.
Order now on Slice
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
davey.barstool2/19/23, 9:52 p.m.
Quite possibly better than Sally's in New haven. Has a different vibe but by God it may very well beat it. One of the best pizzas in existence
ryanloewy1/28/23, 8:39 p.m.
Zero flop, great char on the first slice of this.As i get further into the pizza, though, the flop starts permeating. Excellent crisp nonetheless; marinara has a great zing to it. Fresh mozz with some pecorino Romano cheese really brings up the profile for this. Very similar to John’s of Bleecker in terms of its build and cheese to sauce ratio. This is really good pizza Franklyn, probably among the best in the area. That’s a fucking review Frank!!
stay_moke9/15/22, 11:07 p.m.
This is real deal, New Haven style apizza in the Hudson Valley of NY. If you like thin, crisp, light, flavorful coal oven pizza, you'll love this place.
jt426/7/22, 2:57 a.m.
Nice undercarriage, can taste the fresh basil, sauce is good but could be a bit tastier.
bdbenji12119/4/21, 1:03 a.m.
Best pizza around this area by far. I don’t understand why this idiot below be gave it a 5.0 and said best pizza in the HV.