Arancine's Pizza

Solid 7.0 football pizza.

Tasty slice. Good cook on it and strong sauce tang. Like the grandma and regular here. Location isn't great with some solid options on Jericho. But a hidden gem. New name CATUSCO

It’s called Catusco’s now. Zero flop. Really good taste. Pizza review with my baby girl before she goes to camp, and Aunt Lon and Mom. Sweet sauce. Decent crunch. Good LI pizza.

Now named Catuscos. Hot 🍯

Excellent, great staff, and very good pizza

Slightly above average slice. Some flop. Sauce was decent. Thin, crispy crust. Decent

Enjoyed this slice. Good crisp. Sauce has good flavor. Thin, crispy, a little flip. Cant go wrong with that combo

Good crisp no flop very little grease. Cheese is good. Sauce is good but feel like i can barley taste it. Overall a solid slice. But here's the weird thing. I got two slices the second slice so much better than the first. Sauce is good better crisp like im amazed. Now i see why they were voted best pizza of li. First slice was a 6.6 second slice 7.9 idk how to rate this so i knocked it to a 7.6 for inconsistent. Lady so nice

Where do I start. The pizza is awesome. Perfect amount of sauce, cheese, and perfect amount of crisp on the crust. Recommend everyone to come to Arancine’s. Especially you El Pres. 8.6 that’s a review

Dough felt/tasted uncooked+it was thin crust=red flag. Sauce was decent. Was gonna give 6.1 but the cashier lady was really nice

Solid hometown slices