Light crust, great sauce!
89bron2/25/22, 8:27 p.m.
Definitely unique. Not sure it’s the pizza capital of the world, but definitely glad I tried Old Forge
subdiver2/5/22, 4:54 p.m.
Only a few left, good stuff! Love the softness as you bite into it and finishes with the crunch! Pretty good sauce too.
zachary.worthington1/16/22, 6:28 p.m.
“Pizza capital of the World” is a pretty bold statement. Had my wife with me, and she isnt a big fan of pizza, so i could only try one spot, and i chose this one based on it having the most reviews. As undercooked and heavy as it looks, the dough is nice and crispy on the bottom and super light. The sauce was just red and pastey, the cheese was mehhhh. I could see this “Old Forge Tray Style” being a local favorite, but i’ve tried a lot of pizza, all kinds of styles, and this is just not vibing with me. I had to give it a 7 for the crisp and airy dough.
thomas.hern9/19/21, 9:59 p.m.
Good pizza. Unique. First time having “Old Forge” style pizza. Pleasantly surprised. I boosted it .2 because Donald Trump ate here and the restaurant is proud of it. #TRUMP2024
travis.krueger38/16/21, 5:38 p.m.
Wonderful sauce. Crust has a nice crispness on very bottom but too doughy on top. Cheese was very bland. Reminds me of a slightly thinner Detroit style.
michael.zanfardino8/14/21, 7:15 p.m.
Got the white and red. White was unreal good, so different. I think they use American cheese? Red was good, buttery crust.
robby.wander6/18/21, 7:56 p.m.
I’ve made a pilgrimage to the Pizza Capital of the World at the corner of S. Main St. and W. Grace St. Going to hit up the Old Forge four joints at this intersection - in alphabetical order. I’ve never had a slice of pizza, or a “cut”, quite like this one before. Sauce is sweet, cheese is plentiful, and the crust is pillowy yet crispy at the bottom. Worth the trip; therefore, 8 worthy. The ladies inside could not be nicer - or have a thicker Italian accent.
griffin_foll3/4/21, 5:26 p.m.
Pizza Capital of the World. White tray a little too cheesy for my liking.
brian.pawling2/27/21, 8:49 p.m.
Thick but light crust. Was expecting more flavor and probably had a little too much cheese. The cannoli was much better than the pizza.
jonathon.stack12/24/20, 8:16 p.m.
This pizza has been ate by the two greatest president(é)s the world has ever known, Donald Trump & Dave Portnoy, so you know it has to be good. Light and fluffy crust with a flavorful sauce.