Not much crisp.... Good cheese.... Tasty sauce...
griffin_foll3/4/21, 5:26 p.m.
Pizza Capital of the World. White tray a little too cheesy for my liking.
brian.pawling2/27/21, 8:49 p.m.
Thick but light crust. Was expecting more flavor and probably had a little too much cheese. The cannoli was much better than the pizza.
jonathon.stack12/24/20, 8:16 p.m.
This pizza has been ate by the two greatest president(é)s the world has ever known, Donald Trump & Dave Portnoy, so you know it has to be good. Light and fluffy crust with a flavorful sauce.
phillyfoodandbeer11/7/20, 7:48 p.m.
Balanced sauce with just enough tang and a little layer of raw onions that crunch. The crust is nice and chewy with a light crunch on the outer edge. Love those onions!
bret.erney10/26/20, 9:32 p.m.
Not at all what I was expecting. I thought I was going to be blown away. Could have been cooked longer. Decent sauce. Crust is tasty. I don't know what the hype is. Not worth the hour plus drive.
dwightschrute10/19/20, 10:08 p.m.
A little too doughy for me. Pizza by Alfredo could take some pointers.
maddenpizza10/18/20, 4:06 p.m.
Well that’s underwhelming. Cheese is spotty and soft, crust mediocre. I feel like it should be served in elementary school cafeterias by lunch ladies smoking cigarettes.
walter.tillman9/1/20, 4:13 p.m.
Super crispy with a buttery dough that is much lighter then it looks. While it may look like a lunch able, it's a nice amount of cheese and sauce. Not much tang to it, but just a solid tasting slice that's always going to leave you smiling and satisfied (that's what she said). Much like Team Portnoy member Bryce Harper, Old Forge sits roughly at the midway point between Philly and The Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown. Definitely happy to have made the detour to stop here for lunch, and would recommend this to any pizza lover. That's a review!
davidwillow8/22/20, 12:48 a.m.
Had to order on goldbelly and have it shipped. This is based on a frozen pie cooked in a residential oven. We cooked the crust to super crispy. Pizza is doughy (thick like Sicilian) but turned out crispy. Cheeses was light and creamy and sauce was tangy. Although it’s a thicker Sicilian type slice its super light. Extra point for President Trump 2020!!!
make.pizza.great.again8/21/20, 11:46 p.m.
It is on the backs of coal miners’ wives and daughters that the tremendous pizza at Arcaro & Gennell was born. Their homemade dough on those fabulous rectangular metal trays has been delighting the pizza lovers in Northeastern Pennsylvania for generations. Their homegrown tomatoes and spices from their lush Keystone State gardens are a Lackawanna County tradition. In the early years, men would crawl from the mines and head to local taverns like this one as a reward for a hard day of AMERICAN work. Unlike Sleepy Joe Biden and his family of flunkies who never worked a hard day in their lives. One thing is for certain, the Bidens are a Delaware family. Another thing for certain is that my son Barron will never sleep with his dead sibling’s widow. Lyin’ Joe Biden has no pizza roots whatsoever. He may try to claim to be a man of the people, speaking to the likes of Cardi B. Eating this pizza will not throw off your PH Balance! In closing, this pizza gets HIGH GRADES! I highly recommend you eat it as soon as possible, if not sooner, and then take a beautiful long nap on one of Mike Lindell’s My Pillow. Just fantastic.
danny5297/11/20, 6:18 p.m.
Not bad. A little too sweet and doughy for my taste. Could have been cooked a bit longer.
tom.shields4/4/20, 9:28 p.m.
Second try at old forge pizza I would say this one is good not great. May be because I just got a few slices and not a whole pie but crust is too doughy not enough crisp. Also just flat flavor wise. Was expecting more