Arrenello's Pizza

I really wanted to love this one Frankie, I really did after a friend has been hyping it up for a year! Not a huge fan of the sauce as it’s a heavy tomato paste splattered all over the pie and I will admit that’s biased on my part because I prefer cheese over sauce on my deep dish pies but the sauce is just too heavy. Nothing stands out and for the one hour drive to this place, definitely wasn’t worth the trip… sorry Frankie

Great as always! Love the sweet sauce.

Solid pizza. Sweet sauce but maybe a little too sweet. Family run, nice owners. Will return to try deep dish.

Perfect crispy crust with a very sweet sauce.

Pleasant surprise. It’s a sweet sauce. Cheese and sausage was quite tasty tonight!

Well done. That’s the way I like it. The sweetness is Palermo’s-esque.

Sorry no pick but this place is legit. It's legit if you love that sweet sauce and killer ingredients. It can be heavy and a little wet at times but you hit the right cook you are in for a treat. I used to live a couple blocks away. It has been a minute but this is solid for sweet sauce lovers. Lol

Sauce is too sweet

If you like a pie with sweet sauce this is top notch

Sweet sauce. Good cheese. Crispy bottom. A little too saucy but that’s just preference. Overall, good.

Nothing special

Ordered a stuffed with sausage mushroom and spinach. Sauce is too sweet, sausage and spinach were sparse. The crust was soft and too gooey because of the sauce or cheese. Did not like this stuffed pizza. If there is a next time it won’t be stuffed. I don’t order stuffed often; but never again from here. I prefer thin crispy tavern style with sausage.

Excellent sauce and a great thin crust

Incredible sauce, incredible pie. This place trumps most.

Sweet sauce, crispy crust. Fantastic deep dish!