Top Restaurants

Artisan Pizza Cafe

Artisan Pizza Cafe

91 East 5th Avenue, Columbus, Ohio

Pizza Review

0 likes

joshua.l on One Bite Pizza App

joshua.l

1/12/26 12:10 AM

Did not realize a food photo was required until later so receipt verification provided. We ordered two pies (1- Regular w/ beef pepperoni, 1- Deep w/beef meatballs). Owner was very nice and inviting however the pizza(s) was lacking any flavor. Neither pies had any crunch, regular was floppy like a Neo(we ate on site), both pies suffered from little to no sauce or cheese. Maybe a new cook, maybe they haven’t figured out the new ovens, maybe an off night. 6.1 only because they make dough from scratch and service was welcoming but for premium price pies it wouldn’t make any must try list.

Pizza Review

piagod1/31/26, 10:54 p.m.

8.4

My taste buds are acclimated to the northeastern region of the U.S. I’ve had the best of the best in New Haven, CT, Philly, Boston, NYC and all over NJ. And this pie right here is top of the line. Perfect crunch in the crust, only advice is if the undercarriage could’ve been somewhat in between what I had and Dave’s pizza, I think this would be in the 9’s easily. Cheese stays perfect, very light and doughy. Phenomenal pizza. (The best pies have that sweet taste to the dough, this pizza’s got it). Very nice owners too! Very fast

Pizza Review

benny.131/17/26, 8:48 p.m.

8.4

Pizza Review

pc2.012/19/25, 6:53 p.m.

8.4

Best Pizza in columbus! It was well balanced when it came to the dough, cheese, and sauce! Just one thing: I’m a sauce guy and I wish there was a little bit more sauce but overall an amazing pizza. Amazing undercarriage and it was very light and airy when it came to the crust. It had great texture and crunch. you can taste the char of the crust which added extra flavor. Such excellent flavors for this pizza, great taste and flavors all around. I’d give a solid 8.4!

Pizza Review

onebitebraeden11/2/25, 11:15 p.m.

8.4

Pizza Review

brennan.hunt10/22/25, 1:33 a.m.

6.9

Good pizza, a little overhyped imo. Cheese could be a little more flavorful but good crunch and sauce. Very nice owner!

Pizza Review

bbpizza10/2/25, 9:51 p.m.

8.1

Pizza Review

landon_hall9/21/25, 6:39 a.m.

7.9

Super super solid pizza. Great ingredients, great undercarriage, zero grease. Crust is pretty thick and a little bland but overall really enjoyable pizza. Owner was absolutely lovely, and I got to witness her picking the fresh basil right out of the pot outside. 7.9 from me.

Pizza Review

grantmf9/20/25, 4:48 p.m.

8.6

Pizza Review

banban9/8/25, 10:24 p.m.

8.5

I was just driving by and saw the one and only. I had to give it a try and yeah… it’s amazing. They use fresh ingredients and you can really taste it. I was able to talk to the owner for a good minute while she was making it for me. Sweetest lady ever.

Pizza Review

stoolpresidente9/8/25, 10:00 p.m.

8.1

1,325 views•87 likes