Fairly greasy, fairly zesty sauce, decent slice. The price point was the worst point.
Order now on Slice
Order Aurelio's Pizza - Fishers
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
pouchpizza3/3/22, 11:31 p.m.
Kinda floppy with a crisp around the edges, good blend of cheeses but maybe a little too much as it makes each bit kinda chewy. Sauce is good and a unique taste, pepperoni was fresh tasting. Honestly gets better as you get towards the edge where there's a little less cheese and more crisp
josh.ritter7/23/21, 11:08 p.m.
A little heavy, a little greasy, decent flavor. Not the worst. Not the best.
pizza.junkie8/10/20, 6:28 p.m.
Kinda floppy with a crisp around the edges, good blend of cheeses but maybe a little too much as it makes each bit kinda chewy. Sauce is good and a unique taste, pepperoni was fresh tasting. Honestly gets better as you get towards the edge where there's a little less cheese and more crisp.
andrew.ward57/27/20, 12:48 a.m.
This is the stuffed crust. It only comes as the deep dish. Amazing! The sauce was steaming when it was brought to the table. We had pepperoni with mushrooms, and the toppings were generous. Lightly topped with a little Parmesan and basil. The overall bake was perfect with an excellent crunch to the stuffed crust. If you can see in the pic, the pizza is elevated on a rack above the pizza pan to keep the undercarriage from getting soft.
tim.earnest2/8/20, 12:09 a.m.
Alright Frankie, not bad. Thin crust is very crispy. The prez would say the sauce is a little tangy. Good but not great. That’s my review...
elias.handford2/3/19, 9:13 p.m.
Good overall pizza. Cheese and meats were really good, not a lot of flop and thought it could be a little less saucey. Nothing to tell your grandkids about but good pizza. Definitely low-balled my score here but can’t change it that’s the rules.
tyler.rose21/19/19, 2:23 a.m.
We ordered the super sox the works Pizza was all over a good pizza. The slices feel heavy and are loaded with toppings that do not fall off the slice like most pizza. Bosco Sticks would give a 7.5 not a fan of the dipping sauce. Only negatives we had was the pizza is a $25 dollar pizza and the menu to many options.
jessy.fyffe-flory1/14/19, 10:29 p.m.
This is my perfect 10 pizza! Sauce is out of this world 1 fiesta everyone knows the rules
shawn.hall11/14/19, 8:52 p.m.
Had there super 6 which was recommended! It was fantastic very good quality ingredients and crispy crust! Will be back for more
haley.nicole1/14/19, 5:27 p.m.
Best pizza in fishers growing up in chicago this was the go to spot for our family!!! need to review and try this pizza mecca! they do it right! from the crust to the sauce to the cheese!
277 views•3 likes
mike.stevens21/14/19, 5:22 p.m.
Sauce is out of this world!!! It’s addictive and makes you want to keep eating one bite everyone knows the rules!! Crispy crust it’s the best pizza I’ve had!
jackson.seward12/15/18, 12:15 a.m.
Sauce is good, crust is even better. But wayyyy too fucking salty which brought the score way down.
therealpizzaking9/20/18, 4:22 p.m.
Thin crust is the way to go in my opinion. Extra sauce on top of the pie is a must. General manager and rest of the staff are extremely nice and personable.