Baker's Pizza Sports Shack ( Bucyrus, OH )

Great tavern style pizza with a delicious crackery crust

This was the traditional crust. Wasn’t sure what that meant when I ordered but it is a tavern style. This pizza is right up my alley. Nice zesty sauce (not sweet at all). I don’t like sweet sauce. Crispy edges really one of the better pizzas I’ve had while traveling for work. They don’t skimp on toppings. Maybe a little heavier than I would prefer but the pizza was great. Kinda pricey though.

Solid pie! Crispy and cooked well. Great neighborhood joint.

Great local pizza with great ranch!

Good pizza. Could use more sauce and a little more well done than our liking. Definitely zero flop

Nice & Thin. Good sauce & good cheese.

A atheistically pleasing pizza but more meets the eye. Probably one of the best looking pizzas I’ve come across. When it’s piping hot the flavors really mesh well. Beautiful crust, minimal flop, very very greasy. Once it starts too cool down you really only taste the partially solidified grease. Solid pie.

Noticed they had a “hand tossed” option with “crushed tomato sauce” on the menu so I ordered a second pie and I’m glad I did. The sauce was far more acidic and the crust had zero flop and lots of crunch. It was served with garlic dipping sauce but it wasn’t needed. The toppings were cooked perfectly.

Flop fest! Taste good..

This place lives off the reputation of their signature pies. When they don’t have any toppings to hide behind you’re left with mediocrity.

the highest score I have ever given. Great crisp with a very good tangy sauce. Don't pass by this place

Best pizza in this area. Especially if it’s well done. Crust is crunchy cheese has nice tang. Great pizza worth the 25 minute trip.

Crust and dough had a nice crisp. Would’ve liked to taste the sauce more. A little too much grease and cheese. Overall solid pie.

Got a large traditional pizza with old fashioned pepperoni, Italian sausage, with fresh mushrooms on one half and green olives on the other half. Pick up order and it was hot. Cut in squares. No flop. A little greasy which I am okay with. Right amount of cheese. Thin crust was crispy. Old fashioned pepperoni was excellent. Sauce was tangy, no sweetness. This is a solid, good pizza. Similar to Donatos but better.

Very good and crispy! Added bonus, Bakers fries with a kick is a must!

Great crust, awesome specialty pizzas! The Caribbean is legit.