Balistreri's Italian-American Ristorante

Voted best pizza in Milwaukee and I can see why! Very good with thin crust which is good but I prefer more dough. Good amount of toppings and I really like the way they cut it, especially bringing kids with us!

Must order extra crispy. Sauce is nice and sweet. Cheese is so fresh and crust is nice when extra done. Best I've had in WI. Would recommend. Their cheese bread is also fantastic.

🐐 pizza and by far the best pizza in Milwaukee.

The very best. Superb undercarriage. Minimal flop. Very cheesy.

Pizza is sloppy. Crust has no flavor, the sauce is runny, the cheese is oily and slides off with the toppings. End pieces are more cooked than the middle pieces.

One of the best pizza’s in the milwaukee area!!! Super thin crisp crust, sauce is very flavorful and has a good tang, very good cheese! A little on the greasy side but I like that

Among the top dogs in Milwaukee

Little flop, good tangy sauce, nice crisp

Solid pizza. I think they are one of the better places in mke. Love this place. Atmosphere is great. Great date spot. If the crust was crispier it would of hit an 8. Staff was great.

Solid Milwaukee style pizza, shame they don’t have banana peppers.

Very thin crust, great sauce. Great ingredients. HIGHLY recommend.

Flaky, crispy crust. A little greasy. Good sauce to cheese ratio.

Might have take more than one bite.

Fresh taste, great sauce