BAR

Pepperoni & Black Olives Meatball, Ricotta & Basil

Are f@king kidding me? Lobster roll pizza was amazing! Everything was delicious. Thin crust. Amazing ingredients. Classic New Haven.

First New Haven spot and very disappointing, $31.50 and closest they have to a regular cheese pizza. Margherita with fresh moz sliced tomatoes basil and garlic. Notice the weird cuts, very thin very floppy seems like Neapolitan crust, can barely tell there’s any cheese, flavor is okay. Everyone always said potato and bacon is the go to here and normally I suggest plain everywhere but you can skip it here and go with the wild toppings.

Most underrated slice in New Haven

A tale of two pies. Close to the crust the pie is thin and crispy but the center starts getting soupy. Very thin. Very good taste. Could have been higher if center didn't flop out.

Solid taste but it's just too thin. Beyond normal New Haven style thin so it's not as satisfying

Super thin. Great flavor, good crust.

Good crust, super thin great pie.

Portnoy doesn’t know his ass from his elbow when it comes to food. Bar is unreal

Flops

If Colony and Pepe’s had a baby

Better than Sally’s and Pepe’s

Thin crust, a lot of cheese and sauce which is good. Resulted in flop, but again, I’m not against that. Good taste, not too salty. Prob my favorite New Heaven style Pizza.

Reformative

definitely has a distinct taste, just too thin of a crust for my liking and not enough sauce

Super crunchy! And the sauce has great flavor

Very thin pizza but very tasty

Pizza was perfectly cooked and delicious! Definitely would recommend!